Short Takes : Yoga is ok, yoga-politics is not


 – Dr Mohammad Manzoor Alam –

MUKHTARABBASNAQAVI copyOn its own, yoga is like other systems of exercise that promote physical, mental and emotional wellbeing. Despite its origins in a Hindu religio-cultural milieu, its widely acknowledged “founder”, Patanjli, was said to be an agnostic. Even then, practices like Surya Namaskar (literally, bowing to the Sun), that makes it look like Sun worship, and emitting the Hindu sacred word Om during breathing exercises make it belong to the vast body of Hindu religio-spiritual ritual.

However, there is more to RSS-BJP’s exuberant support of Yoga Day celebrations as has been pointed out by opposition parties’ leaders. They have alleged that behind the Yoga Day celebrations the Sangh was trying to mobilise and indoctrinate people in a jingoistic way against non-Hindus. Political leaders and media commentators have drawn attention to provocations like those the BJP MP Adityanath, an uncouth oaf with a foot-in-the-mouth affliction, likes to make against Muslims. This man declared recently in a grand, magisterial way, “Those who refuse to do Surya Namaskar must go to Pakistan.”

Certainly, it is a remark against Muslims, who cannot, should not, will not, engage in Sun worship or snake worship, or any other worship, except the worship of Allah. It is in moments like this that the ulterior agenda of all things emanating from the Sangh entail becomes clear. They try to infuse even an innocent thing like yoga with a mischievous spirit. As I said, on its own, nobody has an objection to yogic exercises if things likeSurya Namaskar and chanting of Om are not imposed on monotheists.

In fact, there are many Muslims who do yogic exercises regularly without, of course, resorting to Surya Namaskar and Om chanting. The Subcontinent’s premier Islamic seminary, Darul Uloom Deoband, has said that for Muslims yoga is good enough, minus practices like Surya Namaskar and Om chanting. This stands to reason even though yoga’s genesis lies in ancient Hindu milieu. Exchange of good ideas between Islam and other cultures is an established norm as indicated practically by the United Arab Emirates, which has marked two days for Yoga Day celebrations, instead of one day by any other country, including India, the home of yoga.

That Islam does not frown at such exchanges is obvious from the widespread use of prayer beads (also known as worry beads) by the devout across the Muslim world, even though the beads originated in Buddhist ritual. Likewise, the fast on Ashura came into Islam after centuries of its observance in Judaism. The Prophet (PBUH) introduced it to Islam saying Moses (PBUH) belonged to Muslims more than he did to Jews.

As it stands, cultural exchanges are fine with Muslims, but politicisation of such things is not. Going beyond all limits of legitimacy and decency, the Sangh has tried to drag the Vice-President of India into controversy. BJP general secretary Ram Madhav tweeted that Vice-President Mohammad Hamid Ansari’s “absence” from the yoga session was noted. Obviously, it was a slur on the Vice-President, with the sly implication that he had kept himself away from it because he was a Muslim. Naturally, this was noted by leaders of non-NDA parties. Congress leader Jairam Ramesh said, “Communal polarisation is the only thing that Modi, Amit Shah and Ram Madhav know…Whatever the BJP and the PM do is aimed at communal polarisation.”

He added, “This obnoxious tweet by Ram Madhav, knowing fully well the constitutional position of the Vice-President, is a deliberate and mischievous attempt at polarisation and at giving yoga a communal flavour.”

Soon the Vice-President’s office clarified that the ministry dealing with the event had not invited the Vice-President in the first place. Minister of State for AYUSH, Shripad Naik, whose ministry was looking after the Rajpath yoga event, apologised for the tweet. He also explained, as the PM was the chief guest at the event the Vice-President was not invited because his constitutional position being superior to the PM’s, the PM cannot be the chief guest in his presence.

This shows not only the constant slander campaign against the Vice-President, but also an attack on the dignity of the second highest of constitutional office in the country. And, this is not for the first time they have targeted Vice-President Ansari.

Earlier, on the eve of Republic Day, they spread the rumour that Mr Ansari had not saluted the national flag. That, too, was an attempt to show that as a Muslim his loyalty to the nation was suspect. In that case, too, the veep office explained that the protocol required that he should not salute the flag while the President was doing it.

Recurring attacks on the veep like this indicate that it is not the significance of Republic Day or the value of yoga that is on BJP leaders’ minds, but some ulterior agenda as Jairam Ramesh has pointed out.


About the Author 

Dr. Mohammad Manzoor Alam

Dr.-Mohammad-Manzoor-Alam-invc-news1Dr. Mohammad Manzoor Alam is an erudite Islamic Economist and Social Scientist. He has been associated with Institute of Objective Studies (IOS) as its Chairman for over 25 years now. Dr. Manzoor Alam, a Ph.D. in Economics from Aligarh Muslim University, has held various high-ranking positions in many international organizations such as Economic Advisor in the Ministry of Finance and National Economy, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia; Associate Professor Deptt. of Islamic Economics, University of Imam Mohammad-bin-Saud, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia; Chief Coordinator for the Translation of Meaning of the Holy Quran in different languages of the world at King Fahd Holy Quran Printing Complex, Madinah Munawwarah, Saudi Arabia; Chief Representative of International Islamic University, Malaysia (IIUM) in India; Member of the General Committee of the IDB Scholarship Program for Muslim Communities in Non-Member Countries, Islamic Development Bank, Jeddah, K.S.A.; Consultant of the International Institute of Islamic Thought, USA in India; Founder Member of International Islamic Charitable Organisation, Kuwait; and Member, Steering Committee, Istanbul Talks, Civil Solidarity Platform, Istanbul, Turkey.

Dr. Manzoor Alam holds membership on the board of many international journals as well. He is Member of the Advisory Board of MEDAD, published from the KSA; Member of the International Advisory Board of American Journal of Islamic Social Sciences, published from the USA; and Member of the Advisory Board of Awqaf, published from Kuwait.

In India, apart from being Chairman of Institute of Objective Studies (IOS), Dr. Manzoor Alam is ably guiding the Indian Muslim community with his vast experience by serving in different capacities such as General Secretary, All India Milli Council, New Delhi; President, Indo-Arab Economic Cooperation Forum, New Delhi; President, Indian Association of Muslim Social Scientists, New Delhi; and Member of All India Muslim Personal Law Board.
Under his stewardship, Dr. Manzoor Alam has successfully transformed the Institute of Objective Studies to being India’s foremost, pioneering and only organization in the country engaged in generating knowledge in Islamic Perspective, Educational development of Indian Muslims, Research, holding Conferences, seminars and workshops on vital issues, Publications and Advocacy for Muslims and other weaker sections’ causes.

Address for Communication

Institute of Objective Studies 162, Jogabai Main Road ,P.O. Box 9725, Jamia Nagar , New Delhi-110025 (India)
Mobile – +91- 9810157494 – email:

*Disclaimer : The views expressed by the author in this feature are entirely his  own and do not necessarily reflect the views of INVC .


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here